26 men were captured during a raid by the Germans on night 21/22 March 1918

During the night of March 21/22nd, we did experience a real touch of the offensive in the shape of a big raid on the right Company, the most vulnerable portion of the line on the whole Brigade front. This front, which was held by A Company was of enormous length, extending from Railway Craters on the right to Munster Parade on the left, a distance of about 600 yards.

Three platoons (about 60 all told) held the outpost line in small posts of four or five men, each under a N.C.O., the fourth platoon being held in support as a counterattacking platoon in Old Boots Trench at the West end of Munster Tunnel. The latter was about 400 yards behind the outpost line, and was also occupied by the support Company, and contained the right Company Headquarters. The orders laid down were that in case of attack the platoon detailed for the task was to counter-attack either through the tunnel (quite impossible if the enemy obtained a footing in the trench at the tunnel mouth) or over the top.

Shortly after midnight, the enemy put down an intense barrage of trench mortars, wing bombs, and shells of all calibres, along the whole of the Brigade front and support lines, forward communication trenches, Battalion Headquarters, the Village Line, and extending even to roads, villages, and batteries far behind the line. Telephone wires were broken immediately, but the “S.O.S.” was sent by signal rocket and power buzzer, and our artillery and machine guns replied at once. There had been no preliminary bombardment or warning of any kind.

The enemy entered our trenches directly behind his barrage from the cover of the craters on the right, between our right post and the left Company of the 138th Brigade, who were on our right, also near Dundee Walk in the centre, and just North of Munster Tunnel on the left. Such wire as had been put up by the few men who were usually available was swept away by the hurricane bombardment, which prevented movement of any kind, either to or from the front or support lines.

Two runners were wounded whilst attempting to take messages between Company Headquarters and Munster Tunnel, a distance of 50 yards. The posts in the front line were unable, owing to their small numbers, to offer any prolonged resistance, or on account of the distance between them, to assist neighbouring posts.

The front line entrance to Munster Tunnel was held by us the whole time, and an attempt to blow it in, which was one of the main objects of the raid, was frustrated, 2nd Lieut. Hartle being wounded by a hand grenade. That the garrison of the outpost line withstood the onslaught to their utmost there is no doubt, and to this the pools of blood and reeking bayonets of some of the rifles found afterwards in the trench, bore convincing testimony.

After the enemy’s withdrawal, one unwounded and one seriously wounded German were left in our hands, the former having apparently become detached from his party, and being discovered later in front of our trench with a sheet of newspaper fluttering from his rifle.

The thoroughness with which the Boche trained for this raid was proved from the prisoners’ statements and documents, which afterwards came into our hands. For six weeks the raiding party, consisting of about 250 men, had been training over an exact replica of our trenches, constructed with the help of an aeroplane photograph. The training had also included the teaching of several words of English. The work of the raiders was extraordinary, and our own men in the front line testified to the remarkable dexterity with which they removed their casualties. This is the more wonderful inasmuch as they had to penetrate our barrages, in order to regain their trench, and there is no doubt that in doing so they lost heavily.

Our casualties amounted to three other ranks killed, including a very gallant N.C.O., Corpl. Tyne, 26 other ranks missing, and one Officer (Hartle), and ten other ranks wounded. We should like to pay tribute to the excellent work done by the Signallers, who as usual worked their hardest, to try and keep their lines in order, in spite of the heavy shelling. L.-Corpl. Parry’s efforts to repair the broken lines back from one of the front Companies, were especially praiseworthy.

The wounded Officer was Elias William Hartle from near Crich – see here

Elias William Hartle

The men killed were:-

307131 Pte Sidney Samuel Ives who lived at Walworth in Surrey and left Charlotte and a young son Sidney George who was born in 1916.

305752 Cpl Harold Tyne DCM was from Southwell and arrived in France in May 1915. See here.

305625 Pte John Thompson. Son of B. Thompson of Mansfield; husband of Rhoda Thompson of Heathfield, Cale Green, Stockport. John arrived in France in August 1915.

The men taken prisoner were:-

‘Kriegs gefangenen – sendung’ sent from Privates 9462 John Knowles and 11585 Edward Mathews from Nottingham.

Sent by John Knowles in May 1918 from Chemitz POW Camp
Sent by Edward Mathews to Miss Ord in March 1917 from Soltau POW Camp

John Knowles was born in July 1886 and enlisted into the Sherwood Foresters in June 1904 aged 18.

Edward Matthews was born in August 1892 and enlisted into into the Sherwood Foresters in March 1911 aged 19.

Medal Index Card for John Knowles
Medal Index Card for Edward Matthews
Men of the 2nd Battalion training in 1913

John Knowles and Edward Matthews arrived in France with the 2nd Battalion Sherwood Foresters (Notts & Derby) Regiment on the 8th September 1914. The 2/Sherwood Foresters were part of the 18th Brigade in the 6th Division.

Regimental History of the 1st and 2nd Battalions Sherwood Forester. Event of the 20th October 1914
Map of engagement

Edward Matthews was captured on the 20th October and John Knowles on the 28th October. In total over 480 men of the 2nd Battalion were captured.

Record of Edward Matthews capture on the 20th October 1914
Record of John Knowles capture on 28th October 1914
1914 Medal Roll for the 2nd Battalion showing the number of men made prisoners of War

After returning to England both John and Edward received a Princess Marys Christmas Tin.

Record of John and Edward receiving the Christmas 1914 Tins

John married Florrie and they had three children. he is believed to have died in 1946. It is not know if Edward was married with a family, but he is believed to have died in 1965.

71138 Pte Enoch Thorley of the Chatsworth Rifles

Victory Medal
Burslem Town Hall

Enoch was born in The Town of Burslem in the County of Staffordshire in 1885 and was a collier by trade.

Attestation into the Militia

In June 1902 Enoch enlisted into the 3/North Stafford Regiment of Militia aged 17. His attestation form describes him as 5 ft 2 inches with brown hair and grey eyes.

Statement of Service

After serving for 4 years in the Militia he joined the Regular Army.

Enumeration Book for 1911 Census

It is not known how long Enoch stayed in the Army, but certainly by 1911 he is reordered as serving in Peshawar with 2nd Battalion the North Staffordshire Regiment.

Medal Index Card

Enoch attested into the North Staffs Regiment in December 1915 as part of the ‘Derby Scheme’. He was mobilised in June 1916 and following training proceeded to Base Depot in France.

War Diary – Chatsworth Rifles – November 1916
Service Record of 71108 Pte Arthur Chell

Enoch was part of a ‘Draft’ of 50 North Staffordshire men that were posted to the Chatsworth Rifles on the 11th November 1916 and given service numbers 71097 to 71146. The Service record of 71108 Pte Arthur Chell suggests that these men had initially been posted to the 3/8th Battalion North Staffs for training.

Trench Map of St Pierre Divion from WO95/2584/3
War Diary entry for the attack on St Pierre Vivion WO95/2587/2

Almost immediately Enoch Thorley and the other men from the North Staffordshire Regiment were involved in the attack to capture St Pierre Divion. The Battalion successfully captured the German positions and in total captured 13 Officers and 720 Other Ranks. Casualties for the Chatsworth Rifles amounted to Lieut SG Burch and 4 Other Ranks killed; 67 Other Ranks wounded.

War Diary for 21st-25th December 1916 from WO95/2587/2

The Chatsworth Rifles were transferred to the Ypres Sector in November 1916 with the rest of the 39th Division. They relieved the 17th Battalion the King’s Royal Rifle Corps in the right sub-sector. These trenches were located on the Yser Canal just in front of Boesinghe.

Front line trenches

On the 23rd and 24th of December the Germans bombarded the front line trenches with Minenwerfer and shrapnel causing casualties. In total 5 men were killed and 20 wounded; amongst them was Enoch Thorley.

Enoch suffered a gunshot wound to the face, which was described as slight in the Admissions Book of the No 18 General Service Hospital based at Camiers. He had arrived by 18 Ambulance Train on the 26th December. This record also confirms that Enoch had only been in France for 2 months prior to his wounding. He was transferred to the 6 Canadian Hospital on the 10th January 1917.

Enoch was discharged in February 1918 and received a pension. The Pension record describes his wound as GSW (gun shot wound) to the thighs; it is therefore possible that Enoch returned to the Chatsworth Rifles and was wounded a second time.

Enoch was awarded The Victory Medal, British War Medal and a Silver War Badge.

3588/241139 Pte Walter Gratton from Bonsall

Walter was born in 1883 and was limestone quarryman. He enlisted into the Sherwood Foresters in December 1914 and was serving with the 3/6th Battalion in February 1916

Around August 1916 Walter was posted to the 1/6th Battalion and sent to France (information taken from XI CCS Admission and Discharge book). In March 1917 he suffered from a septic knee and was sent to the XI Casualty Clearing Station in Varennes. Seven other men from the 1/6th Battalion were also sent by sick convoy to the XI CCS.

Walter was still serving with the 1/6th Battalion when they attacked Hunter and Scotts Post between 30th August and 3rd September – see here. Walter was one of four men killed that day and they are buried in  FOUQUIERES CHURCHYARD EXTENSION, Plot IV, Graves F1-3 & 8.

Fouquieres Churchyard Extension, France

His parents (Benjamin and Mary) lived at 3 Rose Cottage, Upper Town in Bonsall, Derbyshire and after the War received a pension.

Letter “L” (2nd Chesterfield) Company, 2nd Volunteer Battalion the Sherwood Foresters (Notts. and Derby) Regiment

This post card was most likely taken at either the 1906 (Conway) or the 1907 (Towyn) Summer Camps – I favour Towyn.

L Company (2nd Chesterfield) 2nd Volunteer Battalion the Sherwood Foresters (Notts. and Derby) Regiment
2VB Notts and Derby Shoulder patch

Easily recognisable are:-

Captain Arthur John Hopkins (St Helen’s Lodge, Chesterfield)

Lieut HP Taylor (Grasshill House, Grassmoor)

Col.Sergt-Instr James Arthur Sturges (Drill Hall, Chesterfield)

Col.-Sergt J Harrison (St Helen’s Street, Chesterfield)

Sergeant James Needham

Sergt John H Platts

70702 Pte Edward Greatorex

Shoulder badge
BWM and VM roll entry for Edward Greatorex

Edward Greatorex served overseas with both the 1st and 1/5th Battalions of the Sherwood Foresters. Edward was posted to the 1st Battalion with a draft of about 90 men on the 21st September 1916.

The 70000 series of Regimental Numbers were initially used to transfer men from the Territorial (Reserve) Battalions to the Regular and New Army Battalions of the Sherwood Foresters to make up for loses sustained in the Battle of the Somme.

This would suggest that Edward was possibly from the Nottinghamshire/Derbyshire region. Indeed, Greatorex is a very uncommon name and only seven other men called Edwards Greatorex served with the British Army during WW1


On May 8th 1918 ‘A’ sent a postcard from Lincoln to Edward in Summerdown Camp in Eastbourne (from c/o Mrs Heaps of 17 Clarina Street in Lincoln).

Dear T. Had a tram ride today, the weather is a1 & quite warm…might go to Conisboro [sic] tomorrow as B4….A….hope you are a1.”

Summerdown Camp

Summerdown Camp opened in April 1915 and was the first, and at the time the largest, of three purpose built convalescent camps designed for rehabilitation of the wounded from the First World War. Of the 150,000 injured and sick soldiers who passed into the camp, 80% were sent back to fight.

This postcard would suggest that Edward had been wounded in the trenches and was convalescing in England. It’s possible that this occurred between his service with the 1st and 1/5th Battalion. Edward was in hut 16 B Division with the Notts & Derby.

But who was Edward Greatorex, ‘A’ and Mrs Heaps?

The last question is the easiest to answer…….Lucy Heaps was the (second) wife of Charles William Heeps, a carpenter and joiner originally from Northamptonshire. They had one daughter Winifred Emma who was born in 1896.

The Heep’s Census return on 1911

A search of the 1911 Census for ‘Edward Greatorex’ with search terms ‘born in 1896 +/- 10 years’ and ‘Lincoln’ only identified a few plausible candidates.

Edward, born in 1893 in Derby who was blind.

Edward, born in 1892 in Wirskworth and was tape weaver.

Edward, born in 1900 in Nottingham, but would have only been 14 at the outbreak of War.

Despite no obvious link to Lincoln I can only assume that the card was sent to Edward Greatorex from Wirksworth.

Lost graves of the Royal Scots; the personal stories of three men

In searching the WW1 Army Service Records online I came across a single (torn) page making reference to four isolated graves, in various locations, of men that had died in 1918. The record had been made by a ‘Graves Registration Unit’, but no date was recorded.

The names and details of three of these men were also listed and all men had served with The Royal Scots.

I was intrigued as to whether I could discover the stories of these brave men and find the location of the graves on a contemporary trench map.


335833 Pte Thomas Scott, 8th Royal Scots

“Isolated grave near Hinges, 10 miles S.S.E. of Hazebrouck”

Private Scott was difficult to identify because there was no soldier with that name and regimental number that was killed on the 18th July 1918. However, a further search of CWGC identified 335833 Pte Thomas Scott, aged 22, who was k/a on the 23rd July as the most likely candidate. Unfortunately, it would appear that Thomas’ body was not recovered after the War and he is now Commemorated on the Soissons Memorial.

The Soissons Memorial commemorates almost 4,000 officers and men of the United Kingdom forces who died during the Battles of the Aisne and the Marne in 1918 and who have no known grave.

Thomas was the son of of Robert and Susan Scott of 10 Morningside Square, Newmains, Wishaw in Lanarkshire.


11354 Pte John Henry Poyner, 2nd Royal Scots

“Protestant Cemetery, The Hague”

John Poyner died one day after the Armistice on 12th November 1918, aged 25. He was the son of William and Annie Poyner of 72 Bradbury Lane, Hednesford in Staffordshire and was born at High Town, Cannock, Stafford.

James was a coal miner and enlisted into The Royal Scots (Lothian Regiment) on the 4th January 1913, aged 18, having previously served with the 5th Battalion North Staffs Regiment.

2nd Battalion Royal Scots 1913

He arrived in France on the 11th August 1914 and was captured unwounded by the Germans on 26th August 1914 at Caudry. and was interned in Hamelu and Diepholzer POW Camps.

John Poyner MIC

Caudry town was the scene of part of the Battle of Le Cateau on the 26th August 1914; see here for more details.

26th August 1914

John was originally reported as killed in action on the 14th September 1914 (Casualty List No. 1778), but in November his mother received a postcard from him stating that he was a prisoner of war.

Prisoner of War letter
Post card received from John Poyner

At some point John appears to have been wounded and transported for internment in Holland, where he died.

Army Service Record
Record of John Henry Poyner’s death in the Netherlands

59731 Pte James Park, 11th Royal Scots

“W. side of Row of Pill Boxes, S. of Sans Some South of Roulers Railway, 3 miles E by N. of Ypres

James Park was from Glasgow in Lanarkshire and served overseas with the 16th, 12th and 11th Battalions of the Royal Scots, which suggests that he may have been wounded several times and moved between different Battalions of the Regiment following his convalescence.

BWM and VM entry for James Park
James was killed in action on the 28th September 1918

After the War James’ body was exhumed and reburied in August 1918 in Perth China Wall Cemetery. Interestingly, although the Graves Registration Unit recorded that his was an ‘isolated grave’, he was actually buried alongside Frederick William Bruback of the 27th Field Ambulance RAMC. The record also provides a precise location of their graves.

IWGC reburial record

The War Department trench maps shows that this was a very heavily defenced area and well-known Pill Boxes such as Kit and Kat and Anzac are recorded.

Trench Map from early 1917 showing a strong German position at 0.0 in square J2 C
A line of three blue boxes at 0.0 in Square J2 C may be reference to the ‘W. side of Row of Pill Boxes’ recored in the original grave registration.

What happened on the 28th September 1918?

War Diary entry for the 11th Royal Scots on 28th September 1918

The 11th Royal Scots, which was part of the 9th (Scottish) Division, attacked German positions to the north east of Ypres. The 27th Field Ambulance were attached to the Division.

“5.30am. Battle commenced in terrible weather, torrents of rain, progressive however was good and all objectives were taken.”

Weather cleared at 12 noon and wounded who were numerous were cleared without difficulty by night fall”

“Work for bearers is very heavy and 4 bearers of 27 FA were killed”

It is interesting to speculate that the 27th Field Ambulance had an Advanced Dressing Station in one of the abandoned Pill Boxes and that is were both James Park and Frederick Bruback died and were buried.

A German Pill-box : used as British battalion headquarters, Ypres (Art.IWM ART 542) image: a concrete pill-box, with the entrance on the right side. A soldier stands to the right, while mud and debris is on the left. Communication wires strung between trees are above and to the right of the pill-box. Copyright: © IWM. Original Source: http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/12905

241616 Pte Joseph Archibald Robinson

Joseph Archibald Robinson was born in Bakewell, Derbyshire on the 27th December 1895. He was the eldest of 5 children born to Frederick and Helena Robinson. By 1911 the family had moved to Spa Lane in Chesterfield. Joseph – aged 15 – was a telegraph messenger.

Joseph enlisted into the 3/6th (or 2/6th) Battalion Sherwood Foresters (Notts & Derby) Regiment in late December 1915/early January 1916. His 4-digit service number was most likely 4657. It is highly likely that Joesph served in Ireland during the Easter Rising of 1916.

The 2/6th Battalion marched out of No. 6 Camp at Hurdcott (Fovant) on 25th February and proceeded to Folkstone where they proceeded to Boulogne.

On the 21st March 1918 the Germans launched their Spring ‘Kaiserschlacht’ offensive and the 2/6th – like the rest of the 178th Bde of the 59th Division – were effectively annihilated.

But what happened to Joseph?

On the 21st April 1918 Joseph’s mother – Helena – sent a request to the War Office enquiring about her son Joseph, who she had (presumably) not heard from for a while.

A very worried mum.

Joseph was reported as ‘missing’ – along with 657 other men of the 2/6th.

On the 27th March 1918 Joseph was able to send a ‘Pro-Forma’ card to Helena informing her that he was a POW – but alive and well!

It clearly took a while to arrive in Chesterfield – see paragraph.

Joseph eventually found himself interned in Dulman POW camp and was able to send a photo back to his mother….

“Dear Mother, how do you like me in my ‘Gefangeners’…….”

Joseph – along with other men of the BEF – was released from captivity and returned to the UK. I have not traced his name on any repatriation lists, but man of the 2/6th men captured on the 21st March were repatriated in November and December 1918.

Joseph was awarded the Victory Medal and British War Medal.

Joseph married Ada Elizabeth Yeomans at the Parish Church in Chesterfield on 2nd August 1920.

After the War Joseph served as a Special Constable (his father was a Railway Policeman) rising to the rank of Sergeant.

He was awarded the The Special Constabulary Long Service Medal (George VI issue) for 10 years service.

It is not known if he attended the Annual Reunion of the 2/6th Battalion held in Bakewell in 1935.

Joseph and Ada moved to Hasland and he worked as an Electricity Board Storekeeper. Joseph died at the Royal Hospital on the 4th February 1974, aged 79.

The End